Skip to content
General History
  • Home
  • World History
  • European History
  • English History
  • French History
  • Spanish History
  • Rome
May 29, 2013
A History of North America US History World History

America’s Supreme Court

The Supreme Court building / becketfund.org
The Supreme Court building / becketfund.org

Most developed countries have a Supreme Court, which means what it says.* It is the maximum legal authority a third branch of the government, independent however of the legislative (Congress or Parliament) and the Executive (The President or Head of State); yet it is only a small body of highly qualified judges, appointed in the case of the United States by the President, with the agreement of the Senate or Upper House. There were only nine members when the Court was established in 1869, and they held and hold their place in the Supreme Court for life.

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • Share this:
  • Related

In America the court rapidly claimed the right to decide if laws passed by Congress or state legislatures were constitutional. It could only do so when cases arising from a particular law were brought before it. The following rather laboured phrase was famously used: ‘We are under the Constitution but the Constitution is what the judges say it is, and the judiciary is the safeguard of our liberties and our property’.

Since the late nineteenth century the Supreme Court’s decisions have been important in deciding whether power lies with the states or with the federal government. Thus the social and economic development of the US has been affected, sometimes guided. But, and it is a big But, the Court has no means of enforcing its judgements, which means it must rely on the President. Some presidents have not cared too much about the Court’s decisions.

Some Chief Justices have said very odd things during sessions of the Supreme Court. C.J Marshall said many state laws were unconstitutional and in one case an Act of Congress was declared so! Later C.J. Taney said that ‘blacks are beings of an inferior order’ (it was the nineteenth century) and added that Congress had no right to ban slavery in any state, a speech that helped start the American Civil War.

In 1896 the 14th Amendment to the Constitution gave black people ‘the equal protection of the laws’, but the Supreme Court was not in any way enamoured of ‘black rights’, and maintained racial segregation by upholding the ‘Jim Crow Laws’.

From 1890 to 1930 the Court limited federal attempts to control trusts, to establish worker’s rights to form a union, or to limit the number of children working in an adult’s job. In the first administration of Franklin D. Roosevelt (1933-7) the Court declared 12 New Deal laws unconstitutional. This displeased Roosevelt who asked Congress for a Bill allowing him to appoint more liberal judges in the Supreme Court. He did not get far with this radical proposal, and in fact had to withdraw it, as opposition was too strong. FDR was seen as trying to threaten the judiciary’s independence – which of course he was – but this independence was guaranteed by the Constitution, though the threat had alarmed the judges. They upheld laws which they might possibly have opposed, such as the Social Security Act providing old age pensions for the elderly, unemployment insurance, and a helping hand for the trade unions.

*Spain has a Supreme Court which is apparently not as ‘supreme’ as some would like. There is also a Constitutional Court which recently upset a decision pronounced by the ‘Supreme’ Court.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Related

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Author

‘Dean Swift’ is a pen name: the author has been a soldier; he has worked in sales, TV, the making of films, as a teacher of English and history and a journalist. He is married with three grown-up children. They live in Spain.

Buy General-History Books on Amazon

Sources & Bibliography

Encyclopaedia Britannica
Oxford Encyclopaedia of World History
Chambers Dictionary of World History
New Penguin Dictionary of Modern History
The Spectator

Works of:
Andrew Roberts
Antony Beevor
Adam Nicholson
John Sutherland
Paul Johnson
George Macdonald Fraser
Sir Iain Moncreiffe of that Ilk
Christopher Lee
Dan Jones
Paul Massie

Recent Posts

  • Could Francisco Pizarro Have Conquered the Inca Empire Without the Inca Civil War?
  • Why Are jersey nba basketball and cheap soccer jerseys Shaping Global Fan Culture Today?
  • Why Historic Market Towns Like Thirsk Are Still Worth Visiting
  • Beyond the Frame: How Glass Walls and Crittall-Style Designs Are Transforming Modern Interiors
  • How Families Pass Language and Learning Traditions Between Generations

Recent Comments

  • FatDave on History of the Cinema: ‘The Wild Geese’
  • miss shermyra nahveta on Jack The Ripper and the British Royal Family
  • Dale Nail on The Battles of Little Bighorn & Wounded Knee
  • Dean Swift on The real Sir William Wallace
  • RR on The real Sir William Wallace

Categories

  • A history of Australia
  • A history of Hungary & Austria/Hungary
  • A History of North America
  • A History of Poland
  • A history of the motor car
  • African History
  • Asian History
  • Austrian history
  • British History
  • Church history
  • Commercial
  • Commonwealth History
  • Commonwealth of Nations
  • Czech History
  • Dutch History
  • English History
  • English Language
  • Estonia, A History
  • EU History
  • French History
  • German History
  • Greek History
  • History
  • History in The Balkans
  • History of Afghanistan
  • History of China
  • History of Czechoslovakia
  • History of Egypt
  • History of Finland
  • History of haute cuisine
  • History of India
  • History of Ireland
  • History of Japan
  • History of Korea
  • History of New Zealand
  • History of Portugal
  • History of Rome
  • History of the Cinema
  • History of the Far East
  • History of the Low Countries
  • History of Turkey
  • Humour
  • Italian History
  • Jewish History
  • Philosophy
  • Romanian History
  • Russian history
  • Scandinavian history
  • Scottish history
  • South American History
  • Spanish History
  • Swiss History
  • The Arab races
  • Today
  • US History
  • World History

License

Creative Commons License
©2026 General History | Powered by WordPress and Superb Themes!